• Apply
  • Archives
  • NewsWatch
  • Classifieds
  • Multimedia
    • Ole Miss in Puerto Rico
    • Campus Protests
    • The Queen of Marks
    • Meet Aubrey Armstrong, a Real Champion and Local Celebrity
    • Mississippi voters passed Initiative 65. What’s next?
    • One year later: COVID-19 at Ole Miss
    • “It’s Just Not Fair”: One Woman’s Fight For Access to Community Water
    • A way with words
Tuesday, January 31, 2023
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Mississippian
  • News
    The only sober ones in the room: Oxford bartenders serve as a safety net

    The only sober ones in the room: Oxford bartenders serve as a safety net

    Being the first: First generation students share experience, struggles and misconceptions

    Being the first: First generation students share experience, struggles and misconceptions

    ASB passes preferred pronoun policy

    ASB passes preferred pronoun policy

    The reality of NIL

    The reality of NIL

    Artificial intelligence presents new challenge to the university

    Artificial intelligence presents new challenge to the university

    Video of arrest sparks controversy

    Video of arrest sparks controversy

  • Sports
    Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

    Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

    Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

    Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

    Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

    Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

    The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

    The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

    Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

    Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

    Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

    Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

  • Arts & Culture
    New semester, new music: a list of spring semester’s most anticipated albums

    New semester, new music: a list of spring semester’s most anticipated albums

    The music venues that make Oxford

    Who’s coming to Oxford this spring

    Long awaited “The Last of US” makes HBO debut

    Long awaited “The Last of US” makes HBO debut

    New movies light up the box office

    New movies light up the box office

  • Opinion

    The Black experience: something greater than just me

    Staff Editorial: Too much

    Cameras in the classroom and useless image politics

    A year 2 remember

  • Print / e-Editions
  • Advertise
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Policy
    • Classifieds
  • Contact
  • News
    The only sober ones in the room: Oxford bartenders serve as a safety net

    The only sober ones in the room: Oxford bartenders serve as a safety net

    Being the first: First generation students share experience, struggles and misconceptions

    Being the first: First generation students share experience, struggles and misconceptions

    ASB passes preferred pronoun policy

    ASB passes preferred pronoun policy

    The reality of NIL

    The reality of NIL

    Artificial intelligence presents new challenge to the university

    Artificial intelligence presents new challenge to the university

    Video of arrest sparks controversy

    Video of arrest sparks controversy

  • Sports
    Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

    Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

    Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

    Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

    Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

    Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

    The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

    The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

    Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

    Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

    Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

    Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

  • Arts & Culture
    New semester, new music: a list of spring semester’s most anticipated albums

    New semester, new music: a list of spring semester’s most anticipated albums

    The music venues that make Oxford

    Who’s coming to Oxford this spring

    Long awaited “The Last of US” makes HBO debut

    Long awaited “The Last of US” makes HBO debut

    New movies light up the box office

    New movies light up the box office

  • Opinion

    The Black experience: something greater than just me

    Staff Editorial: Too much

    Cameras in the classroom and useless image politics

    A year 2 remember

  • Print / e-Editions
  • Advertise
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Policy
    • Classifieds
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Mississippian
No Result
View All Result

Cameras in the classroom and useless image politics

Justice RosebyJustice Rose
January 22, 2023
Reading Time: 3 mins read

As you may know, the Mississippi legislature has been in session since early this month. With the state in optimal financial position relative to past years, you’d think the senators and congressmen alike would have their hands’ full divvying up the $3.9 billion surplus. 

In true politician fashion, valuable time has been wasted with the introduction of vanity bills. Bills that serve little to no practical purpose. Bills that would do much more harm than good. The one that really caught my attention was house bill 278. HB-278 proposes installing cameras and surveillance equipment in Mississippi classrooms. Perhaps, the law could be justified for safety purposes. For various reasons (guns), classrooms have become increasingly dangerous. Instead, the listed reasoning for the bill is for districts “to monitor classroom instruction, to monitor classroom interactions, and teacher observation.” A red flag shoots up. 

My question is why. Why do classroom lectures need to be recorded and potentially reviewed? Why do classrooms need twenty-four-hour real-time observation? That sounds like a nightmare for teachers, students, and districts. Surveillance would make students hyper-aware of what they’re saying, which isn’t exactly ideal for a learning environment. Not because high school students are spewing dangerous rhetoric, but because they are self-conscious kids who don’t want to be embarrassed. If anything at all, this would silence what should be an empowering setting. It’s important to mention that the verbiage in the bill makes it difficult to access the footage. With that being said, the physical presence of a surveillance camera will undoubtedly alter classroom behavior. 

For teachers, I’d be concerned about saying the wrong thing and potentially facing punishment. Even though the bill does not list repercussions, it does suggest that in appropriate contexts insubordination will be viewed and dealt with on a district level. Then, each district will have to define insubordination because the bill does not. This differing and vague definition could suppress teachers’ personalities, and makes classrooms less like a think-tank and more like a prison cell. 

For districts, I’d be stressed. The bill states that districts are tasked with contracting companies to install and maintain the surveillance system, and district staff will be responsible for reviewing the footage.

For taxpayers, I’d be confused. There are a million things that have precedence over this pseudo-issue: the water crisis, the lack of hospitals, the struggling healthcare system and the education overhaul, to name a few. 

Monitored education is something we usually liken to Russia, China or North Korea. It’s a totalitarian policy that seems foreign through our red, white, and blue tinted glasses. Evidently, it’s much closer to home than we think. 

The thing is, HB-278 has gained little to no traction and wasn’t a pressing topic to begin with. Undeniably, it would increase safety and deter bad behavior. It’s expensive, impractical, and unnecessary, though. Honestly, I believe it was introduced primarily for the image. Image politics is probably the defining issue in American policy-making. How much is being done to address legitimate problems versus how much is being done to secure re-election and win twitter points? 

 

Justice Rose is the opinion editor. He is a sophomore journalism major from Madison, Miss. 

 

In Case You Missed It

Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

14 hours ago
Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

14 hours ago
Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

14 hours ago
The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

14 hours ago
Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

2 days ago
Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

2 days ago

Cameras in the classroom and useless image politics

Justice RosebyJustice Rose
January 22, 2023
Reading Time: 3 mins read

As you may know, the Mississippi legislature has been in session since early this month. With the state in optimal financial position relative to past years, you’d think the senators and congressmen alike would have their hands’ full divvying up the $3.9 billion surplus. 

In true politician fashion, valuable time has been wasted with the introduction of vanity bills. Bills that serve little to no practical purpose. Bills that would do much more harm than good. The one that really caught my attention was house bill 278. HB-278 proposes installing cameras and surveillance equipment in Mississippi classrooms. Perhaps, the law could be justified for safety purposes. For various reasons (guns), classrooms have become increasingly dangerous. Instead, the listed reasoning for the bill is for districts “to monitor classroom instruction, to monitor classroom interactions, and teacher observation.” A red flag shoots up. 

My question is why. Why do classroom lectures need to be recorded and potentially reviewed? Why do classrooms need twenty-four-hour real-time observation? That sounds like a nightmare for teachers, students, and districts. Surveillance would make students hyper-aware of what they’re saying, which isn’t exactly ideal for a learning environment. Not because high school students are spewing dangerous rhetoric, but because they are self-conscious kids who don’t want to be embarrassed. If anything at all, this would silence what should be an empowering setting. It’s important to mention that the verbiage in the bill makes it difficult to access the footage. With that being said, the physical presence of a surveillance camera will undoubtedly alter classroom behavior. 

For teachers, I’d be concerned about saying the wrong thing and potentially facing punishment. Even though the bill does not list repercussions, it does suggest that in appropriate contexts insubordination will be viewed and dealt with on a district level. Then, each district will have to define insubordination because the bill does not. This differing and vague definition could suppress teachers’ personalities, and makes classrooms less like a think-tank and more like a prison cell. 

For districts, I’d be stressed. The bill states that districts are tasked with contracting companies to install and maintain the surveillance system, and district staff will be responsible for reviewing the footage.

For taxpayers, I’d be confused. There are a million things that have precedence over this pseudo-issue: the water crisis, the lack of hospitals, the struggling healthcare system and the education overhaul, to name a few. 

Monitored education is something we usually liken to Russia, China or North Korea. It’s a totalitarian policy that seems foreign through our red, white, and blue tinted glasses. Evidently, it’s much closer to home than we think. 

The thing is, HB-278 has gained little to no traction and wasn’t a pressing topic to begin with. Undeniably, it would increase safety and deter bad behavior. It’s expensive, impractical, and unnecessary, though. Honestly, I believe it was introduced primarily for the image. Image politics is probably the defining issue in American policy-making. How much is being done to address legitimate problems versus how much is being done to secure re-election and win twitter points? 

 

Justice Rose is the opinion editor. He is a sophomore journalism major from Madison, Miss. 

 

In Case You Missed It

Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

Rebels run wild at Razorback Invitational

14 hours ago
Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

Ole Miss men’s tennis falls to Princeton

14 hours ago
Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

Lady Rebels claw back to stun the Razorbacks in overtime: Three takeaways

14 hours ago
The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

The short-handed Rebels become a casualty of the Big 12-SEC Challenge

14 hours ago
Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

Ole Miss’ top prospects declare for the 2023 NFL Draft

2 days ago
Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

Summarizing Ole Miss’ transfer portal additions

2 days ago

Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
Mississippi Press Association

Sign up for The Morning Briefing, our newsletter with the top news of the day.

SUBSCRIBE

  • News
  • Sports
  • Arts & Culture
  • Opinion
  • Print / e-Editions
  • Advertise
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Policy
    • Classifieds
  • Contact

All Rights Reserved to S. Gale Denley Student Media Center 2019

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Sports
  • Arts & Culture
  • Opinion
  • Print / e-Editions
  • Advertise
    • Advertise with Us
    • Ad Policy
    • Classifieds
  • Contact

All Rights Reserved to S. Gale Denley Student Media Center 2019

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
-
00:00
00:00

Queue

Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00