• Apply
  • Archives
  • NewsWatch
  • Classifieds
  • Multimedia
    • Ole Miss in Puerto Rico
    • Campus Protests
    • The Queen of Marks
    • Meet Aubrey Armstrong, a Real Champion and Local Celebrity
    • Mississippi voters passed Initiative 65. What’s next?
    • One year later: COVID-19 at Ole Miss
    • “It’s Just Not Fair”: One Woman’s Fight For Access to Community Water
    • A way with words
  • Subscribe to our newsletter
Wednesday, July 9, 2025
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Mississippian
  • News
    • All
    • Associated Student Body
    Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

    Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

    University cuts support for Oxford Pride

    University cuts support for Oxford Pride

    ASB expands legislative council, elects Wesley Templet president pro tempore

    ASB expands legislative council, elects Wesley Templet president pro tempore

    What goes into making Commencement happen for 5,500 graduates?

    What goes into making Commencement happen for 5,500 graduates?

    Stamps Impact Prize awarded to 15 students

    Stamps Impact Prize awarded to 15 students

    MPower sets on a new path amid low attendance

    MPower sets on a new path amid low attendance

  • Sports
    • All
    • Game Recap
    House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

    House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

    Ole Miss Softball takes series against Missouri

    Ole Miss Softball advances to World Series for first time in program history

    Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

    Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

    Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

    Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

    Ole Miss Softball dominates Rocket City Softball Showcase

    Ole Miss Softball battles through SEC Tournament

    Ole Miss softball falls to No. 1 Tennessee

    Ole Miss softball falls to No. 1 Tennessee

  • Arts & Culture
    Seniors cement their campus legacy with a brick

    Seniors cement their campus legacy with a brick

    Student photographers capture picture-perfect graduation moments

    Student photographers capture picture-perfect graduation moments

    Julien Baker & TORRES ‘send a prayer’ to Oxford

    Julien Baker & TORRES ‘send a prayer’ to Oxford

    Double Decker 28 rocks the Square

    Double Decker 28 rocks the Square

    Grove trees cared for by the Department of Landscaping Services. Photo courtesy: Jillian Russell

    An ode to campus trees and those who care for them

    ‘Sinners’ falls flat on first watch

    ‘Sinners’ falls flat on first watch

  • Opinion
    • All
    • Ask a Philosopher
    • Diary of a Black Girl
    • From The Editorial Board
    • Lavender Letters
    • Letters to the editor
    lavender letters graphic, a purple envelope with a purple letter, "lavender letters" is written in bold black font on the letter

    Lavender Letters: senior sign-off

    Diary of a Black Girl: senior sign-off

    Diary of a Black Girl: senior sign-off

    Opinion: How to avoid summertime sadness

    Opinion: How to avoid summertime sadness

    Ask a Philosopher: How do I quell my public speaking fears?

    Ask a Philosopher: Why do other people not understand me?

    A farewell from Opinion Editor Justice Rose

    A farewell from Opinion Editor Justice Rose

    Why evangelical Christians need to feel the heat on climate change

    Why evangelical Christians need to feel the heat on climate change

  • Special Projects
    • All
    • It's a Whole New Ball Game
    • Jordan Center Symposium
    • Rising Tides & Temperatures

    Jordan Center debuts with symposium addressing impact of social media, AI on democracy

    Richard Lui: News media must not make same mistakes with AI that it did with social media

    Elise Jordan: Artificial Intelligence will completely transform world

    Elise Jordan: Artificial Intelligence will completely transform world

    danah boyd: Journalism connects people in a healthy social fabric

    danah boyd: Journalism connects people in a healthy social fabric

    Meetali Jain holds Big Tech accountable

    Meetali Jain holds Big Tech accountable

    Dana Milbank asks, ‘Can free press survive the Trump era?’

    Dana Milbank asks, ‘Can free press survive the Trump era?’

  • Print / e-Editions
  • About Us
    • Applications
    • Advertise
      • Advertise with Us
      • Classifieds
    • Contact
    • Editorial Board
    • Policies
    • Daily Mississippian Staff 2025-26
  • News
    • All
    • Associated Student Body
    Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

    Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

    University cuts support for Oxford Pride

    University cuts support for Oxford Pride

    ASB expands legislative council, elects Wesley Templet president pro tempore

    ASB expands legislative council, elects Wesley Templet president pro tempore

    What goes into making Commencement happen for 5,500 graduates?

    What goes into making Commencement happen for 5,500 graduates?

    Stamps Impact Prize awarded to 15 students

    Stamps Impact Prize awarded to 15 students

    MPower sets on a new path amid low attendance

    MPower sets on a new path amid low attendance

  • Sports
    • All
    • Game Recap
    House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

    House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

    Ole Miss Softball takes series against Missouri

    Ole Miss Softball advances to World Series for first time in program history

    Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

    Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

    Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

    Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

    Ole Miss Softball dominates Rocket City Softball Showcase

    Ole Miss Softball battles through SEC Tournament

    Ole Miss softball falls to No. 1 Tennessee

    Ole Miss softball falls to No. 1 Tennessee

  • Arts & Culture
    Seniors cement their campus legacy with a brick

    Seniors cement their campus legacy with a brick

    Student photographers capture picture-perfect graduation moments

    Student photographers capture picture-perfect graduation moments

    Julien Baker & TORRES ‘send a prayer’ to Oxford

    Julien Baker & TORRES ‘send a prayer’ to Oxford

    Double Decker 28 rocks the Square

    Double Decker 28 rocks the Square

    Grove trees cared for by the Department of Landscaping Services. Photo courtesy: Jillian Russell

    An ode to campus trees and those who care for them

    ‘Sinners’ falls flat on first watch

    ‘Sinners’ falls flat on first watch

  • Opinion
    • All
    • Ask a Philosopher
    • Diary of a Black Girl
    • From The Editorial Board
    • Lavender Letters
    • Letters to the editor
    lavender letters graphic, a purple envelope with a purple letter, "lavender letters" is written in bold black font on the letter

    Lavender Letters: senior sign-off

    Diary of a Black Girl: senior sign-off

    Diary of a Black Girl: senior sign-off

    Opinion: How to avoid summertime sadness

    Opinion: How to avoid summertime sadness

    Ask a Philosopher: How do I quell my public speaking fears?

    Ask a Philosopher: Why do other people not understand me?

    A farewell from Opinion Editor Justice Rose

    A farewell from Opinion Editor Justice Rose

    Why evangelical Christians need to feel the heat on climate change

    Why evangelical Christians need to feel the heat on climate change

  • Special Projects
    • All
    • It's a Whole New Ball Game
    • Jordan Center Symposium
    • Rising Tides & Temperatures

    Jordan Center debuts with symposium addressing impact of social media, AI on democracy

    Richard Lui: News media must not make same mistakes with AI that it did with social media

    Elise Jordan: Artificial Intelligence will completely transform world

    Elise Jordan: Artificial Intelligence will completely transform world

    danah boyd: Journalism connects people in a healthy social fabric

    danah boyd: Journalism connects people in a healthy social fabric

    Meetali Jain holds Big Tech accountable

    Meetali Jain holds Big Tech accountable

    Dana Milbank asks, ‘Can free press survive the Trump era?’

    Dana Milbank asks, ‘Can free press survive the Trump era?’

  • Print / e-Editions
  • About Us
    • Applications
    • Advertise
      • Advertise with Us
      • Classifieds
    • Contact
    • Editorial Board
    • Policies
    • Daily Mississippian Staff 2025-26
No Result
View All Result
The Daily Mississippian
No Result
View All Result

Opinion: Responding to Nov. 3 statue column

Francisco HernandezbyFrancisco Hernandez
November 6, 2017
Reading Time: 2 mins read

This column is responding to Will Hall’s column “Statue opinion must be challenged” published Nov. 3.

Will Hall’s opinion is nothing new, and it might even seem compelling.  “Confederate symbols exist to remind people of their ancestors; removing them from public spaces is an authoritarian reaction that plays into the hands of a mob mentality” is a fair way to summarize the author’s main point.

However, there are several logical and factual flaws in this apologist narrative.

It’s well-intentioned to say Confederate statues don’t “provide a venue to advance or glorify the disgusting ideology of white supremacy, but rather to remember those who came before us.” But this claim shows a deep misunderstanding of the very goals of having Confederate symbols in public spaces.

It perpetuates the ahistorical perspective of the Lost Cause by omitting that the soldiers being idealized in those public monuments fought a war to preserve and expand slavery. You cannot say those statues exist to remember Confederate soldiers without saying they idealize the cause to expand the right to own human bodies.

Another troubling flaw in the author’s opinion is his neglecting the experiences of the black population in the South and in Lafayette County during and after the war. Hall appeals very effectively to the nostalgic, sanitized views of the Civil War when he says, “The soldier has stood valiantly in memorial to all those who perished alongside him defending their land.”

Perhaps he should consider the slave population of Lafayette County in 1860 — 44 percent of the total. Weren’t Confederate soldiers fighting not only for “their” land but also to preserve the people they considered property and who were forced to work that same land?

As for the claim that removing Confederate statues plays into the hands of an authoritarian mob mentality, this affirmation falls under its own weight. The author wants to avoid that “we surrender our history to the hands of mob rule, where the loudest among us have the ultimate power to choose what history we remember and what history we forget.”

But that is exactly how Confederate monuments came into existence. Weren’t Lost Causers being that “loudest voice,” the one that chose the history that was to be remembered and one that terrorized the lives of the black population for years after the Civil War?

Debates around memory and symbols are not exclusive to the U.S. South. In Spain, many still idealize the genocidal age of imperialism in the Americas as a glorious historical period. After the Spanish Civil War in the late ‘30s, the narrative of fascism as a “savior” for Spain’s “moral decay” became a way to legitimize a dictatorship that lasted until 1975 and whose legacy is still embedded in Spanish right-wing parties.

It’s revealing to look at other countries — like Spain, France, the U.K., Russia and many others — to learn how those in power can distort shameful historical events to their advantage.

To improve our debate on Confederate statues, I encourage Hall to reconsider the factual and logical flaws of his position, to escape his blind commitment to a distorted history and most importantly, to listen to the other side.

Francisco Hernandez is a senior international studies major from Valencia, Spain.

In Case You Missed It

House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

1 month ago
Ole Miss Softball takes series against Missouri

Ole Miss Softball advances to World Series for first time in program history

1 month ago
Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

2 months ago
Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

2 months ago
Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

2 months ago
Ole Miss Softball dominates Rocket City Softball Showcase

Ole Miss Softball battles through SEC Tournament

2 months ago

Opinion: Responding to Nov. 3 statue column

Francisco HernandezbyFrancisco Hernandez
November 6, 2017
Reading Time: 2 mins read

This column is responding to Will Hall’s column “Statue opinion must be challenged” published Nov. 3.

Will Hall’s opinion is nothing new, and it might even seem compelling.  “Confederate symbols exist to remind people of their ancestors; removing them from public spaces is an authoritarian reaction that plays into the hands of a mob mentality” is a fair way to summarize the author’s main point.

However, there are several logical and factual flaws in this apologist narrative.

It’s well-intentioned to say Confederate statues don’t “provide a venue to advance or glorify the disgusting ideology of white supremacy, but rather to remember those who came before us.” But this claim shows a deep misunderstanding of the very goals of having Confederate symbols in public spaces.

It perpetuates the ahistorical perspective of the Lost Cause by omitting that the soldiers being idealized in those public monuments fought a war to preserve and expand slavery. You cannot say those statues exist to remember Confederate soldiers without saying they idealize the cause to expand the right to own human bodies.

Another troubling flaw in the author’s opinion is his neglecting the experiences of the black population in the South and in Lafayette County during and after the war. Hall appeals very effectively to the nostalgic, sanitized views of the Civil War when he says, “The soldier has stood valiantly in memorial to all those who perished alongside him defending their land.”

Perhaps he should consider the slave population of Lafayette County in 1860 — 44 percent of the total. Weren’t Confederate soldiers fighting not only for “their” land but also to preserve the people they considered property and who were forced to work that same land?

As for the claim that removing Confederate statues plays into the hands of an authoritarian mob mentality, this affirmation falls under its own weight. The author wants to avoid that “we surrender our history to the hands of mob rule, where the loudest among us have the ultimate power to choose what history we remember and what history we forget.”

But that is exactly how Confederate monuments came into existence. Weren’t Lost Causers being that “loudest voice,” the one that chose the history that was to be remembered and one that terrorized the lives of the black population for years after the Civil War?

Debates around memory and symbols are not exclusive to the U.S. South. In Spain, many still idealize the genocidal age of imperialism in the Americas as a glorious historical period. After the Spanish Civil War in the late ‘30s, the narrative of fascism as a “savior” for Spain’s “moral decay” became a way to legitimize a dictatorship that lasted until 1975 and whose legacy is still embedded in Spanish right-wing parties.

It’s revealing to look at other countries — like Spain, France, the U.K., Russia and many others — to learn how those in power can distort shameful historical events to their advantage.

To improve our debate on Confederate statues, I encourage Hall to reconsider the factual and logical flaws of his position, to escape his blind commitment to a distorted history and most importantly, to listen to the other side.

Francisco Hernandez is a senior international studies major from Valencia, Spain.

In Case You Missed It

House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

House v. NCAA settlements gets approved, universities can now directly pay athletes

1 month ago
Ole Miss Softball takes series against Missouri

Ole Miss Softball advances to World Series for first time in program history

1 month ago
Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

Ole Miss Baseball wins big at home against UT Martin

2 months ago
Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

Is the university getting closer to a cap on admissions?

2 months ago
Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

Ole Miss Baseball falters on the road against in-state rival

2 months ago
Ole Miss Softball dominates Rocket City Softball Showcase

Ole Miss Softball battles through SEC Tournament

2 months ago

Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
Mississippi Press Association
Sign up for our weekly newsletter!
  • News
  • Sports
  • Arts & Culture
  • Opinion
  • Special Projects
  • Print / e-Editions
  • About Us
    • Applications
    • Advertise
      • Advertise with Us
      • Classifieds
    • Contact
    • Editorial Board
    • Policies
    • Daily Mississippian Staff 2025-26

All Rights Reserved to S. Gale Denley Student Media Center 2019

Republish this article

Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Unless otherwise noted, you can republish most of The Daily Mississippian’s stories for free under a Creative Commons license.

For digital publications:
Look for the "Republish This Story" button underneath each story. To republish online, simply click the button, copy the HTML code and paste it into your Content Management System (CMS).
Editorial cartoons and photo essays are not included under the Creative Commons license and therefore do not have the "Republish This Story" button option. To learn more about our cartoon syndication services, click here.
You can’t edit our stories, except to reflect relative changes in time, location and editorial style.
You can’t sell or syndicate our stories.
Any website our stories appear on must include a contact for your organization.
If you share our stories on social media, please tag us in your posts using @thedailymississippian on Facebook and @thedm_news on X (formerly Twitter).

For print publications:
You have to credit The Daily Mississippian. We prefer “Author Name, The Daily Mississippian” in the byline. If you’re not able to add the byline, please include a line at the top of the story that reads: “This story was originally published by The Daily Mississippian” and include our website, thedmonline.com.
You can’t edit our stories, except to reflect relative changes in time, location and editorial style.
You cannot republish our editorial cartoons, photographs, illustrations or graphics without specific permission (contact our managing editor Michael Guidry for more information). To learn more about our cartoon syndication services, click here.
Our stories may appear on pages with ads, but not ads specifically sold against our stories.
You can’t sell or syndicate our stories.
You can only publish select stories individually — not as a collection.
Any website our stories appear on must include a contact for your organization.
If you have any other questions, contact the Student Media Center at Ole Miss.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Sports
  • Arts & Culture
  • Opinion
  • Special Projects
  • Print / e-Editions
  • About Us
    • Applications
    • Advertise
      • Advertise with Us
      • Classifieds
    • Contact
    • Editorial Board
    • Policies
    • Daily Mississippian Staff 2025-26

All Rights Reserved to S. Gale Denley Student Media Center 2019

-
00:00
00:00

Queue

Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00